Cherry Cake Challenge, Birds and a bit of swiss roll

Mary Berry's Cherry Cake

Friday. Day off. Changeover Day as one daughter is departing for Boston for a long-awaited concert trip and only son is returning from camp for the weekend.

My first delight of the day, before baking, was watching some little birds expertly picking caterpillars off my kale plants. They were very thorough, enjoying their feast and saving me a lot of work. I take notice of the birds a lot more here than I ever did before. Maybe it is because more visit our garden here than in England, maybe it’s because there are more colourful ones, maybe it’s because I know people who have taught me a bit more about them or maybe what one daughter said is true, ‘When people get old they like to watch birds.’ Hmmm.

Anyway onto my first technical challenge. On the Bake Off two nights ago the theme was cake. The three challenges were a Swiss Roll signature challenge where the bakers each made their own recipe of swiss roll, then the technical challenge was Mary Berry’s Cherry Cake and finally, their showstopper was to each make 36 mini classic British cakes. It was all very mouth-watering. Unbelievably I had all the ingredients in the house to make the Cherry Cake so that’s what I was doing second thing this morning. Glancing down the ingredients my heart sunk a little when the recipe called for self-raising flour.

It is a little tricky to convert a British cake recipe to use all-purpose flour. I have to take an educated guess as to how much baking powder or bicarb/baking soda to add. Plus, once I’ve done it I rarely write down what I did for next time I make the recipe, because I think I’ll remember. I don’t, so I have to guess again. This time I guessed two teaspoons of baking powder – I think I could have done with a little less.

Of course it’s not quite the same doing the technical challenge at home as on the show. The bakers don’t have all the instructions, just the ingredients. I had Mary Berry’s tips in front of me…to chop, wash, dry and toss the cherries in flour before adding them to the batter so they don’t sink to the bottom of the cake. So my cherries were pretty ‘well distributed’ as the judges would say. It tastes good I think. I love the little hint of lemon in the cake, it goes well with the cherries and almonds.

Cherry cake

Just to make my first bake-off challenge a little more interesting I thought I’d make a swiss roll. I didn’t do anything fancy, for example ‘Cardamom, pistachio and coffee’ was among the ones on the show (though that sounds good), I thought I’d make a chocolate one. Only thing is I haven’t made a swiss roll since we moved here so again hummed and hahed about whether to add a raising agent. I didn’t. My chocolate swiss roll didn’t go to well. It rose on one side more than the other, and then I think I left it in one minute too long. It cracked as soon as I rolled it. If I was on the show I would have been crying about cake. However, being at home and not liking to be beaten by a cake recipe, I made another one, a vanilla one. I added a half teaspoon of baking soda and baked it for nine minutes precisely…and success, the thing rolled. Happy. I did contemplate not even mentioning the chocolate disaster, but that wouldn’t be in the spirit of the baking challenge so here is evidence that sometimes things go wrong in my kitchen…

swiss rolls

Having said that, guess what everyone chose to have a slice of first, and is almost finished at time of writing…it could only be chocolate.

4 Comments Add yours

  1. Chloe says:

    I love the bake off, I’ve been looking forward to it for so long! I’ve set myself the challenge of baking something from each episode too but I fear it will get a lot harder the further along the series is. Your Cherry Cake looks gorgeous, I think Mary Berry would be proud 🙂 especially as you made it without self raising flour! Your Swiss rolls look equally as good (the crack just gives it a nice homemade touch!)



    1. emmskitchen says:

      Thanks Chloe…yes, it will get harder, pastry week is usually tricky! Good luck with your bakes!


  2. Wendy Lawrence says:

    Emma, that so took me back to 1964. School fete, baking competition. Yes cherry cake. I was 14 and the home economics teacher persuaded me to enter. I got 2nd prize, against the local baker I was very pleased. Both Fiona and Heather bake. Heather for a living Fiona for fun. I love your site.
    Wendy Lawrence ( was Simpson)


    1. emmskitchen says:

      Good to hear from you Wendy and, and good to hear about Fiona and Heather too. Apart from cherries in fruit cake, this was my first time making a cherry cake! So glad that you like the site.


I'd love to hear what you think...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s